The Dark Knight Rises - Flawed And Frustrating
Pubblicato il 3 mesi fa
visualizzazioni 531K
The more I think about The Dark Knight Rises, the more I realise that it's a convoluted, badly written and disappointing end to the Dark Knight trilogy. Join me as I do my best to break down the madness of its plot.
The Critical Drinker
3 mesi fa
Want to help support this channel? Check out my books on Amazon: www.amazon.com/Will-Jordan/e/B00BCO7SA8%3Fref=dbs_a_mng_rwt_scns_share Subscribe on Patreon: www.patreon.com/TheCriticalDrinker Subscribe on SubscribeStar: www.subscribestar.com/the-critical-drinker
Montez Demarrco
Giorno fa
Let's not talk about physics in a batman movie ok
A Keithing
7 giorni fa
Saw in theatre. Instantly thought Bane's voice was Unfrozen Cavemen Lawyer on helium and couldn't get over it. This guy is great btw
Bucket Head Fan
27 giorni fa
@Rob Moran he already did a short one on Tenet- but, id like to see a full length revised version too! Happy Monday Morning from Las Vegas!
Rob Moran
27 giorni fa
You have got to review Tenet. Please!!!!!!!!!! It's like the dark knight rises on steroids, garbage!!!!
Barbatos
28 giorni fa
so...ah... i just want to ask, cuz i was curious, what ever happened to Craig and his mates?
Geeky Nerd73
Ora fa
You realize that almost every Batman story ever written is just as ridiculous!
Will Gee
4 ore fa
Perfect review
B Agamer
Giorno fa
The whole plane scene is ridiculous obviously but no, planes arent designed to withstand high wind resistance at those angles and the wings would be ripped off
Christi A
Giorno fa
*happy to see someone finally talking about how ridiculous that opening airplane scene is* *might I also add how dumb it is that when the bombs go off in the football stadium literally no one runs out of there! really movie?!*
Andrew Thielmann
2 giorni fa
My biggest issue besides all of this - His parents die: he becomes Batman. Droopy Dog dies: he quits for 8 years. WHAT THE F**K.
Donovan Wert
2 giorni fa
Awesome 😎
F. Miller
2 giorni fa
Well I think everybody agree this is the worse of the trilogy. So nothing new.
Martin Hocking
2 giorni fa
Drinker, I have to disagree with you on a particular point in the plot In regards to the opening act with the two planes... While I concede the plot surrounding it unrealistic and ridiculous, the first aircraft bring unaware of another plane coming up behind it is quite conceivable. Airliners don't have mirrors, don't have rear windows, don't have rear cameras and their windows are flush with the body, so rear angled view is limited at best, totally rearward, none. As for radar and transponders, well airliners only have a forward looking weather radar, which wouldn't be able to detect even aircraft ahead of them in any meaningful way. Ground based Primary Radar (the kind which sends out and receives pulses) is only used around the immediate area of major aerodromes (approx 30 nautical mile radius). Other radar (where there is coverage) is Secondary Surveillance Radar, which is dependant on transponders (which can be disabled), and the modern GPS tracking system (ADS-B) can also be disabled, if it's even fitted. So based on that, it is quite possible for the aircraft in front to not be aware of the aircraft behind if it's running dark!
George Wadding
2 giorni fa
Where is the review for "The Dark Knight", my dude? I'd love to see it.
wtiiwarcraft
3 giorni fa
Of Course!
Alex Ya
3 giorni fa
"Ofcourse" 😅😅😅
Rushour717
3 giorni fa
I really liked your life stories
S R
4 giorni fa
So much of this evil master plan is based on coincidence and luck
TRUCKER MARK USA
4 giorni fa
DID THIS MOVIE HAVE SEAN CONNERY AS THE VOICE FOR BANE?
Drew Mac
4 giorni fa
Where's the batman begins review ? Great stuff. Here's to your liver 🍻
Ben B
4 giorni fa
It’s not that bad
Ethan Bradley
4 giorni fa
I think DKR is the best of the dark knight trilogy and I feel no shame in saying that.
Tollah Tv ferkah
4 giorni fa
Don't forget the lackluster fight scenes
megadeth mofo
4 giorni fa
This video was more entertaining than all of the comic book movies combined.
Jason Oquinn
4 giorni fa
Affleck's Batman was in my opinion more like Batman should friggin be, even 20 years into the role. Bane's was weak and ineffectual and the movie was just silly. The 1st 2, yeah good work.
BuRn u
4 giorni fa
i mean i forgot the whole plot....not the worst film but certainly not the most memorable
Dane Nobbs
4 giorni fa
It’s about as good as TENET, which isn’t good at all, it’s pure shite. Fell asleep during TENET in the cinema with its mumbling confusing bullshit.
Hotcosby 42
5 giorni fa
Whether I agree or disagree with you, you still are really funny.
Pratyush Shankar
5 giorni fa
I can prove in 5 words why The Dark Knight Rises was an awesome movie and a satisfying ending to a very entertaining franchise - "Star Wars: Rise of Skywalker".
TheJasonaut
5 giorni fa
Oh man, so good for my soul and sanity, hearing thoughts articulated right outta my head. I really agree with the points about DKR and Nolan generally. 👍
emrik99
5 giorni fa
What I wonder and we will never know is " If Ledger had not died, would the 3rd movie be entirely different,?"
pjetrs
5 giorni fa
When seeing that batman logo on the bridge I always imagine Bruce wayne spending all day hanging on that bridge, whistling along with his radio and carefully painting the bridge with gasoline, making sure it looks just about right for when the city almost blows up because he wanted to be a painter instead of fixing the problem
Alan Kenny
5 giorni fa
If Heath Ledger hadn't died im sure they would have had him in the 3rd film which would have made it more coherent. Probably had a few rewrites after his death.
jryker
5 giorni fa
You are 100% about Gotham losing its character by portraying it as an ordinary city instead of some Gothic utopia/dystopia.
Parker Pshebnisky
5 giorni fa
This movie was the point when Chris Nolan was losing his touch!
gavin Dundee
6 giorni fa
I still love the fact that Bruce travels halfway around the world from his hole in the ground to get back to Gotham within literally about six hours despite not knowing where he is or having any money, passport or transportation about his person to be able to facilitate this. Madness.
Asad Khan
6 giorni fa
@thecriticaldrinker Can’t wait to see you get a hold of Tenet!!
Vato Psyko Loko
8 giorni fa
I always wondered why Bane sounds like Mr. Magoo.
Chuy
8 giorni fa
Mooning with intent?
Tarron
9 giorni fa
Oh thank you thank you so much for taking apart this trainwreck of a movie. I almost thought I was the only one getting furious after 10 minutes of watching that mumbling moron. Yes, there seems to be something like a Mary Sue for antagonists. How would you call that?
Dr Martin
9 giorni fa
Of course!
L I L A M
9 giorni fa
Drinking game: take a shot everytime Bane says "Of course"
El Catalan Libanes
10 giorni fa
After Ledger's death you can notice that Nolan lost his enthusiasm about Batman, and he probably shouldn't have done the third one. But without him, there wouldn't have been a third film (Bale would've left for sure). At the same time, if Rises was the result, then... it probably would've been best if they just left it hang in with The Dark Knight. Ironically, they lived long enough to see themselves become the villain.
John Smith
10 giorni fa
Please, do Tenet. I'm very curious to hear your take on that confusing mess.
milcoll73
10 giorni fa
but critical drinker, you came to pretense as an adult. i was born to it. shaped by it.
milcoll73
10 giorni fa
great visuals. great acting. but theres aint no way youre ever goin to love it. dont feel sad (dont feel sad). 2 outta 3 aint bad.
Jack Corman
10 giorni fa
"Then Alfred has another good cry and goes on vacation" the blunt delivery made me crack up
Matt Dubya
10 giorni fa
the Tim Burton Batman movies were so much better. the dark noir and fun factor of them and their follow up cartoon: Batman the animated series from the 90s are how i think of the Batman universe, not these crappy modern films
Jim Jones
11 giorni fa
"Mr Wayne you traded all your money on unsecure stocks and are bankrupt " . " no i didnt if you check your cctv and your records you will find it's the armed militia in the stock exchange with copies of my fingerprints - can i have my money back?".
Emad Aysha
12 giorni fa
The popular revolution in the city is all reference to the 2008 financial crisis. It's very prophetic actually. I saw an interview of an Egyptian economist in the US saying you can't buy ammo anymore because its all been stocked up by angry citizens!!
Emad Aysha
12 giorni fa
'T2 Judgement Day' has logical inconsistencies in it but dramatic effect and themes outweighed those considerations and in key scenes too, but people love and venerate it nonetheless! In the case of Dark Knight Rises, Catwoman is mainly someone who outsmarts her opponents although I have to admit she didn;t have the physical bulk for some of her action scenes. The prison is clearly in Afghanistan and Bane has taken it over to torture Bruce Wayne, mentally, all references to CIA black sites and the war on terror also alluded to in the opening action sequence. The prison itself is a symbol of the US after 9/11 with people being so scared and mistrustful that they imprison themselves, and Bruce Wayne leaping high enough is driven by fear of death, the opposite of a suicide wish (suicide terrorism, extremism), and Bane is also an example of 'blowback' since Liam Neeson's character also fought in this country as a mercinary and the girl that escaped was his daughter, the bastard child of the confrontation between East and West. I also admit that the city of Gotham didn;t look good, a problem in the second movie too, and don't know why.
Headrock
12 giorni fa
When your mom names you "Craig", you're doomed to be a Scottish lout and end up in prison. Same with the Batman trilogy.
Richy Doop
13 giorni fa
I have seen this film at least twice and cannot remember a thing about it. Apparently Tom Hardy is in it. 🦇 Robin appears only never to be seen again and then the next movie Batman fights Superman until they both realise they had fathers and have a homoerotic experience. Bulkcrap.
Daryl Fernandez
13 giorni fa
umm, nope. This is the best of the trilogy, hands down.
Marc Woolward
2 giorni fa
Dosnt mean it’s not bad
pilkers2
10 giorni fa
No
Florb Fnarb
13 giorni fa
The real strengths of the trilogy are the plausibility of the visuals (although I know you apparently prefer the older conception of a more Gothic Gotham) and its villains, all three of which were excellent performances. That said, the movies are overrated. The Bat-voice is terrible, Bale’s costume was grossly inferior to Batfleck’s costume, and the portrayal of Bruce Wayne as a miserable man moping his way through a brief crimefighting career rather than a Dredd-like avenger of the night on a mission to make criminals wet their pants was misguided from the start.
Unmaned Wolf
13 giorni fa
9:34 that’s why this man is brilliant
Rob Mckay
14 giorni fa
Who's Chad?
jcwilder86
14 giorni fa
a great example of nolan being a great director but just a decent wtiter sadly
Channel 14
15 giorni fa
And what does it matter Bane and the guy appearing dead when hes going to take over a major metropolitan area as a highly visible terrorist the very next week, through announcing himself during a NFL playoff game 🤣
DuffinThe Muffin
15 giorni fa
I still loved the movie personally
Joe Boike
16 giorni fa
It’s as good as it gets.
boeingnz
16 giorni fa
One day people will see Tennet the same way as this movie......
bacd 1990
16 giorni fa
You made several good points, but still this move is better then Disney Trilogy Star Wars, or other movies that I watched in last 4 years (with exception of Joker).
pilkers2
10 giorni fa
You haven’t watched much movies then
ClayBornEv1.0
16 giorni fa
The one thing I will say is that in the movie Bruce had the auto pilot fixed and he never actually flew out to sea. Shortly after the scene of him inside the cockpit he had a jetted out and the plan flew itself out until the explosion. That's the only logical explanation of how he would have survived that in any sort
Denis Liber
16 giorni fa
I actually hated tom hardys performance as bane...his stupid voice is getting on my nerves...yeah yeah i know everyone liked him... But hey at least bale is even more stupid with his outrageously bad batman voice
Batman
16 giorni fa
Anne Hathaway is the worst catwoman ever, Halle berry is a better version of the character.
J Noslen
16 giorni fa
Not every sequel movie that comes out can live up to the movie before it. Entertainment wise it is still a great movie and a good end to the most high rated trilogy of all time.
JoshMC2000
16 giorni fa
I know Rises has problems but I Still like all this films.
samuel villarreal
16 giorni fa
Usually I agree with you, but YOUR KIND OF AN IDIOT ON THIS ONE. I agree with you about Gotham
pilkers2
10 giorni fa
No
Ja'Quan Najm
16 giorni fa
I’ve still never watched this movie
Ja'Quan Najm
16 giorni fa
“A spot of bother”
samuel villarreal
16 giorni fa
Only one person escaped from there, and it was a child everyone else who tried failed. Another point of the prison is hope gets stamped out of there, without hope people would not care to escape. Your saying all these what if's but they didn't happen, the U.S. coouldn't intervene because they would activate the bomb, people were too scared to rise up, which is why the criminals had control of the city. The point of the time was to torture Bruce. And why do u keep saying Bane's plan, it was Talia's, and its not like its a BIG spoiler the movie came out a long time ago. And Talia escaped because she was Raz ah Gul's daughter, this is Batman yooo!!!!
samuel villarreal
16 giorni fa
The opening plane shows Americas over confidence, and how they don't see Bane and his people as a threat. Even though that sequence doesn't make sense, it looks awesome it also seems they actually used real planes so not only does it look awesome but IMPRESSIVE. -jammed communications -one man stayed to show the audience their dieing loyalty to Bane -because America did not view them as much of a threat they would've failed to do a detailed investigation I agree with the reactor points
pilkers2
9 giorni fa
@samuel villarreal so your points were America’s overconfident??? Jamming communications for what one man stayed to show there dying loyalty to bane and why is that important? It still makes no sense if America did not view them as a threat? Wdym America? If a plane carrying prisoners crashed general armed forces would go to investigate
samuel villarreal
9 giorni fa
@pilkers2 I'm countering the drinkers points, probably sounded like a huge nerd
pilkers2
10 giorni fa
what?
Xiaojun Ma
17 giorni fa
It's a less disastrous version of GoT S7&8 in my eyes.
Piotr Dudała
17 giorni fa
Tom is one Hardy bada$$.
Brandon Lucia
17 giorni fa
Yes, but. I still like the movie
My names Jeff
17 giorni fa
Nah bro you gotta drop all that and just enjoy, what a trilogy lol
Stephen Goulding
17 giorni fa
Youre right about alot of this but batman is placed in that prison to teach him a lesson (its banes prison) you also missed out the part where they reveal how he survived moving the bomb - he fixed the autopilot but hey miss that out to further prove your point 🤣
Daniel Guerrero
18 giorni fa
you were craig?
Matthew Hyland
18 giorni fa
Just watched Dark Knight Roses and here I am
James Vani
18 giorni fa
Bane wasn't the villain. Ra's Al Ghul was the villain, essentially, and Bane and Talia were enacting revenge on their behalf. The reason why they went to the trouble of crippling Batman and making him watch Gotham tear itself apart instead of just doing so was revenge for killing Ra's. It's what I saw the first time, anyways; a lot of the other stuff this bastard criticizes seems bang on.
Sky
18 giorni fa
But you thought the joker was movie of the year so what do you know.
pilkers2
Giorno fa
@jchg Bluedemon nope
jchg Bluedemon
Giorno fa
@pilkers2 No the dark knight rises id good.
pilkers2
10 giorni fa
Well this movie is still bad
Random Internet Weirdo
18 giorni fa
We're in for a treat when you finally review TENET, assuming you can understand that mess to be able to talk about it.
Spencer Evans
18 giorni fa
"Why didn't they bring two dead bodies so Bane wouldn't have to leave one of his own men behind?" I'M DEAD.
Ya Hu
18 giorni fa
The thing i dont like the most about the movie is that gotham is just new york city
Brian Considine
19 giorni fa
Curious to hear a review of the other two movies. I think Batman Begins was solid and Heath Ledger as Joker was excellent. The analogy of the two friends who ere elevated by hanging around the 3rd friend implies the Drinker thinks only one Batman movie was great and the other two are elevated because of that. My inclination is that two of the movies are good and the 3rd fell. If Ledger hadn't passed history could have been very different here.
Laservolcano Gaming
19 giorni fa
Nah I don’t think so. It’s much worse than the dark knight but it’s as good as batman begins and compared to other superhero films both of them are in the absolute top.
Colin
19 giorni fa
Why is Batman’s armor 100% ineffective against knives? I know a lot of bulletproof material isn’t great against knives, but she didn’t even wind up or stab quickly the knife went through with no force like it was paper.
Petrow Egynyolc
19 giorni fa
Most of your points are absolutely valid but the plane wings were not designed to withstand that amount of pressure on that suddenly increased surface area, so snapping off alignes w real life physics.
pilkers2
10 giorni fa
It’s still stupid the way the wings snapped off like that considering how strong modern planes are
Seanado
19 giorni fa
I watched Memento again today. I hadn’t watched it for years. I didn’t know who Christopher Nolan was when I first saw it. I enjoyed that one.
Billy McGee
19 giorni fa
Anne Hathaway in full leather while bent over on a weird looking motorbike makes my peepee do things I don't want it to! Nobody will make me feel bad for that either😂😂
Spider Jerusalem2049
20 giorni fa
Never saw it 🤔🤷🏼♂️
wrestle4life234
20 giorni fa
The daughter of Ras Al Ghul stabs Bruce in the lower right quadrant... where only the intestines which don’t bleed nearly as much as the mesentery, spleen, liver. I guess because they needed the plot to happen. I also threw a fit in the theater when Bruce was alive in the last scene
Nick Necro
20 giorni fa
I think the only movie that doesn't deserve praise of this trilogy is DKR. Batman begins and TDK are both great movies
pilkers2
10 giorni fa
Batman begins is bad and dark knight is overrated
Nick Necro
18 giorni fa
@jchg Bluedemon Convoluted, nonsensical and over the top. I like the movie, I enjoy it every time I watch it, which is way often. But I recognize is not good
jchg Bluedemon
20 giorni fa
No TKR is good
Alex Dawson
20 giorni fa
Come on... I think Batman begins was quite good, but I agree with The Dark Knight Rises
Craig Feather
20 giorni fa
Hey!!!
aramis
21 giorno fa
This movie doesn’t makes sense but it does at the same time. ykw, it’s a satisfying end to the trilogy.
tom spud
21 giorno fa
The best thing about TDKR was that it was the last one. Unfortunately we later got Tenant. A film in reverse with dialogue that sounds like someone was talking in a sound proofed room. Well done Nolan.
Beverly Nthabeleng
21 giorno fa
Of course 🤣
Hayley dog
21 giorno fa
I recognize that begins is better but I enjoyed returns better
Gardenia 123
21 giorno fa
What about the rope? Batman gets out of the prison underground after two tries (predictable) but only throws the rope back down? Shouldn’t he have helped the rest of the prisoners to get out too.?...come on! at least the one that fixed his broken back?
NyBSfP —
21 giorno fa
Dark Knight Rises is a sick and very watchable movie. Bane is a badass.
Chris Donahue
21 giorno fa
HA HA, DRINKER, YOU REALLY HIT THE MARK WITH THIS ONE BUT FUCK IT, I STILL LIKE THIS MOVIE A LOT. and I also wasn't paying attention to the caps lock and I'm not going back and re-typing it.
Itosalix
22 giorni fa
Upside. This Bane is somewhat better than Batman Forever's interpretation of Bane. Although I prefer the grunts and gruff one syllable word Bane over unintelligible, high pitched voice Bane. OF COURSE!